3
There was submitted a report by the Director of Children's Services relative to the outcome of the Outline Business Cases (OBC) which investigated potential options for improvement of the Johnstone primary school estate, Johnstone High School and Trinity High School. The report summarised the findings and provided a shortlist of options for each project, together with indicative costs. The Outline Business Cases for each project were attached at Appendices 1 to 3 of the report respectively.
During discussion a number of corrections to content of the report were noted as follows:
- page 155 of the report - row 4 in the table should note that the site at Beith Road Playing fields was viable and should be taken forward to the full business case stage;
- page 217 of the agenda - line 6 of the table should have referred to Bargarran Primary School, Erskine; and
- page 217 of the agenda - line 7 of the table should have referred to Broomhill, Inchinnan.
Councillor Paterson, seconded by Councillor Hughes moved that:
"(a) Note the contents of the three OBC documents in respect of the Johnstone
Primary estate, Johnstone High School and Trinity High School, as outlined in
this report;
(b) Note the officers’ assessment of the Netherton Avenue site and agree that a
further detailed report examining the legal, financial and deliverability
considerations associated with this site be presented to the Board for further
consideration. This report should include a comparison with the constraints and
costs associated with the other site options. Members will then be able to take
a fully informed decision on the site ahead of the next stages of delivering
the Council’s Learning Estate Strategy;
(c) Agree to the shortlisted options recommended in the OBC to be taken forward to Full Business Case stage (FBC);
(d) Note the proposal to further develop the shortlisted options during 2026 as part of a FBC, and to present the final recommended option for each business case to this Policy Board early in 2027; and
(e) Note the FBC development budget proposed for each project which will enable technical issues to be progressed to further inform the feasibility of options, allowing a robust final recommendation for each business case in early 2027 to be developed."
Councillor Smith, seconded by Councillor G Graham, moved an amendment as an addition to the motion as follows:
"Board agrees that following today’s board meeting a Member Officer Working Group will be established to allow for dialogue between members of the boards and the Project Team."
Following discussion, Councillors Smith and G Graham, being the mover and seconder of the amendment, agreed in terms of Standing Order 27 to withdraw the amendment.
The motion was accordingly agreed unanimously.
DECIDED:
(a) That the contents of the three Outline Business Case (OBC) documents in respect of the Johnstone Primary estate, Johnstone High School and Trinity High School, as outlined in the report, be noted;
(b) That the officers’ assessment of the Netherton Avenue site be noted and that it be agreed that a further detailed report examining the legal, financial and deliverability considerations associated with this site be presented to the Board for further consideration. The report should include a comparison with the constraints and costs associated with the other site options to allow Members to be able to take a fully informed decision on the site ahead of the next stages of delivering the Council’s Learning Estate Strategy;
(c) That it be agreed that the shortlisted options recommended in the OBC be taken forward to Full Business Case stage (FBC);
(d) That the proposal to further develop the shortlisted options during 2026 as part of a FBC, and to present the final recommended option for each business case to this Policy Board early in 2027 be noted; and
(e) That it be noted that the FBC development budget proposed for each project would enable technical issues to be progressed to further inform the feasibility of options, allowing a robust final recommendation for each business case in early 2027 to be developed.