Notice of Motion by Councillors McCartin and Mack in the following terms:-
"Renfrewshire Council demands that First Minister Nicola Sturgeon immediately withdraws her proposals for re-introducing national testing for primary school children.
Renfrewshire Council acknowledges that there is still a long way to go in trying to bridge the attainment gap in schools, but the failed systems for national testing of young children is a backward step which has a negative, not a positive effect on attainment in schools.
Renfrewshire Council proposes that the Attainment fund which the Scottish Government has distributed to only 7 councils in Scotland should instead be used, as it has been done in England, to support individual children and their schools where they are struggling with their educational attainment. This will give schools, particularly those with higher numbers of pupils struggling with educational attainment, the ability to increase support to those children without redirecting resources from the remaining pupils."
19
There was submitted a Notice of Motion by Councillors McCartin and Mack in the following terms:
"Renfrewshire Council demands that First Minister Nicola Sturgeon immediately withdraws her proposals for re-introducing national testing for primary school children.
Renfrewshire Council acknowledges that there is still a long way to go in trying to bridge the attainment gap in schools, but the failed systems for national testing of young children is a backward step which has a negative, not a positive effect on attainment in schools.
Renfrewshire Council proposes that the Attainment fund which the Scottish Government has distributed to only 7 councils in Scotland should instead be used, as it has been done in England, to support individual children and their schools where they are struggling with their educational attainment. This will give schools, particularly those with higher numbers of pupils struggling with educational attainment, the ability to increase support to those children without redirecting resources from the remaining pupils."
Councillor McCartin, seconded by Councillor Mack, then moved the motion.
Councillor Henry, seconded by Councillor Clark, moved as a first amendment that raising attainment for all children and closing the attainment gap are key priorities for Renfrewshire Council. Council acknowledges the work done by its Tackling Poverty Commission in this regard, highlights the £2m allocated by the Council to Children’s Services and commends the whole service plan to address this issue.
Council agrees with the EIS that assessment is entirely central to teaching and learning, that standardised assessment is a useful addition to the teachers’ toolbox and that this information should be used to inform teacher actions and authority strategy. Council condemns any action by Scottish Government that leads to the publication of raw scores for schools, leading to league tables or teaching to the test.
Council welcomes the recent commitment to additional funding from the Scottish Government but regrets that this will only affect five schools and that Government has indicated that Renfrewshire will be allocated between £100,000 and £400,000 and contrasts that to the £2,145,000 allocated to Dundee, with similar levels of poverty and £1,965,000 allocated to North Ayrshire.
Council further regrets the comment from Paisley MSP George Adam that “funding is going to the right places”, does not believe that this is true when Renfrewshire Council is yet again being short changed by Scottish Government and believes that George Adam should be Paisley’s champion in the SNP rather than the local apologist for Scottish Government.
Councillor Lawson, seconded by Councillor K MacLaren, moved as a second amendment that Council agrees that the new National Improvement Framework will help close the gap in attainment and ensure all children are being equipped with the skills they need. Council agrees that we need to have better information about attainment so that we measure progress consistently and drive forward change.
The new measures will introduce a greater consistency to curriculum for excellence and will not increase teacher workload as they will replace the variety of different assessments already used by most local authorities.
On the roll being called between the motion and the first amendment, the following members voted for the first amendment: Councillors B Brown, Murrin, M Devine, Grady, J Sharkey, M Sharkey, Kelly, Williams, E Devine, Glen, Henry, M Macmillan, Caldwell, Hood, I McMillan, Bibby, Gilmour, Clark, Provost Hall, Councillors Holmes, Harte and Mullin.
The following members voted for the motion: Councillors Mack, McCartin and J MacLaren.
The following members abstained: Councillors Perrie, McEwan, Lawson, K MacLaren, M MacLaren, McGurk, Audrey Doig, Noon and McQuade.
Three members having voted for the motion, nine members having abstained and 22 members having voted for the first amendment, a vote was then taken between the first amendment and the second amendment.
On the roll being called, the following members voted for the first amendment: Councillors B Brown, Murrin, M Devine, Grady, J Sharkey, M Sharkey, Kelly, Williams, E Devine, Glen, Henry, M Macmillan, Caldwell, Hood, I McMillan, Bibby, Gilmour, Clark, Provost Hall, Councillors Holmes, J MacLaren, Harte and Mullin.
The following members voted for the second amendment Councillors Perrie, McEwan, Lawson, K MacLaren, M MacLaren, Mack, McGurk, Audrey Doig, Noon and McQuade
Councillor McCartin abstained.
23 members having voted for the first amendment,10 members having voted for the second amendment and 1 member having abstained, the first amendment was accordingly declared carried.
DECIDED: Raising attainment for all children and closing the attainment gap are key priorities for Renfrewshire Council. Council acknowledges the work done by its Tackling Poverty Commission in this regard, highlights the £2m allocated by the Council to Children’s Services and commends the whole service plan to address this issue.
Council agrees with the EIS that assessment is entirely central to teaching and learning, that standardised assessment is a useful addition to the teachers’ toolbox and that this information should be used to inform teacher’s actions and authority strategy. Council condemns any action by Scottish Government that leads to the publication of raw scores for schools, leading to league tables or teaching to the test.
Council welcomes the recent commitment to additional to additional funding from the Scottish Government but regrets that this will only affect 5 schools and that Government has indicated that Renfrewshire will be allocated between £100,000 and £400,000 and contrasts that to the £2,145,000 allocated to Dundee, with similar levels of poverty and £1,965,000 allocated to North Ayrshire.
Council further regrets the comment from Paisley MSP George Adam that “funding is going to the right places”, does not believe that this is true when Renfrewshire Council is yet again being short changed by Scottish Government and believes that George Adam should be Paisley’s champion in the SNP rather than the local apologist for Scottish Government.